 |
| Barbara Berlusconi graduated |
July 20, 2010 (the Republic) with a thesis on the economy
Indian Amartya Sen, Nobel prize in 1998, Barbara Berlusconi has now graduated with honors in philosophy at San Raffaele in Milan.
Indian Amartya Sen, Nobel prize in 1998, Barbara Berlusconi has now graduated with honors in philosophy at San Raffaele in Milan.
Barbara was the first to be heard by the committee. During the announcement came at the San Raffaele Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who sat to hear the announcement ceremony, held by Don Luigi Verzè rector, to which the premier was very close. At the end there was the traditional launch in the air of touch, the hat of graduates. The announcement was also attended by his companion of Barbara, George Valaguzza, and two brothers Louis and Eleanor, Veronica Lario, but not the mother nor her two children. And a teacher at the San Raffaele Verzè argues with Don: "That ceremony has outraged teachers and students"
July 22, 2010 (Corriere.it)
degree to Barbara, there is a case
The charge of Professor . De Monticelli: violated the principle of equal dignity. The rapporteur
: mud on our work "There have been proposals for work and does not discriminate against other '
MILANO - Roberta De Monticelli, Professor of Philosophy at the University of the person Vita-Salute San Raffaele, found Tuesday morning it was quite unusual" excluded "from the jury by Barbara Berlusconi, daughter of Prime Minister and Veronica Lario, who graduated cum laude with a thesis on" The concept of well-being freedom and justice in the thinking of Amartya Sen, "Nobel Prize for Economics in 1998.
explains the surprise, "especially in relation to the fact that I was the only one that had been in committee the previous day, morning and evening, and it would have been for the four subsequent discussions that the young Berlusconi. " Do not want to do speculation, and especially points out: "I do not ever there was a suspicion that I was intentionally excluded." It simply observe the facts, driven by love for parresia, "telling the truth," that is convinced, "a Catholic soul, even as Don Verzé.
The teacher already holding in Geneva of the chair that once belonged to Jeanne Hersch (with Hannah Arendt and Raymond Klibansky the best student of Jaspers), recalls: "With my colleagues we had arranged to meet again the next morning at 9 Leonardo da Vinci in the classroom, which would be discussed in five theses. Was scheduled at 9.30 am the first candidate. My presence in the committee, however, was programmed from 10. Then I realized that the first was Barbara Berlusconi. " The announcement followed her in the audience. That is where, when Don Luis Verzé spoke, it was not recognized in the words of the rector. Roberta De Monticelli, in fact, "every word is stone, it's location, and contribution to the clarity and honesty," is calibrated on the basis of 'a role and context. " For this reason, the exchange between the rector and Barbara Berlusconi seemed "unreasonable": "Ask her, and not one of the other four graduates could arise if a faculty of Economics and the author's thought at issue in his case before the President of the Council, contained an implicit request for funding. And Barbara Berlusconi, who perhaps could also become a great economist, he answered "yes."
So he wrote a letter published by the Republic and taken up by other newspapers to "openly and publicly dissociate themselves from a breach of the principle of equal dignity." The university responded by stating that 'was not an offer of employment nor discriminate against other neodottori. He even added: "He who attends Don Luis knows that he considers our students are our first teachers. To stay, to continue studying, is the invitation he does, always, to everyone. " Hundreds of students and former students wrote to the professor to thank. No links at the San Raffaele. Yesterday, indeed, the faculty council was to establish herself among the "Any Other", the theme of the register kept by the rector. "They told me I absolutely disagree with my position in the manner and form."
on the content of the thesis, however, does not want to intervene: "I praise you would have if I had held that the claim had not been worthy. But I was not a committee, I can only rely on the opinion of colleagues. " It would be rather curious to read the final work done by Barbara Berlusconi: "I I had requested the secretariat to Veronica Milani, but there were no copies. " The thesis supervisor, Roberto Mordacci, welcomed the statements of my colleague with despair: "They throw mud on the work already done by the University. We will pay an image effect that is completely false to reality. She wanted to denounce this attitude a bit 'gigione by Don Luigi, but who knows him knows that he has done precisely that. He just wanted to encourage Barbara Berlusconi to become worthy of a post of lecturer. " And before closing states: "Here we are not all Berlusconi: I am writing to Europe and I worked on intellectual initiatives of the Democratic Party."
Elvira Serra
----------
LETTER
"That ceremony for Barbara Berlusconi has offended us teachers and our students'
A letter from a professor at the University San Raffaele after graduating daughter Premier
"The rector Don Verzè addressed only to her, in the presence of Prime Minister, offering a chair"
of Roberta De Monticelli
"That ceremony for Barbara Berlusconi has offended us teachers and our students'
teach philosophy of the person the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita Salute San Raffaele. I am writing this to say: not in my name. It is certainly not in my name that our rector, Father Louis Verzi, acting as his right to the ceremony of the proclamation of degrees, then turned to the only candidate Barbara Berlusconi, who arrived at the conclusion of his three-year course and asked if he thought he could be born a faculty of economics San Raffaele based on the author's thought on the issue in the thesis (Amartya Sen), and an invitation to become professor of this university, in the presence of the Prime Minister, who attended the ceremony.
mean openly and publicly disassociate myself from this I think is a violation not only of the formal principle of equal dignity of students, not only of form and substance of an act as a public proclamation of degree, not only the dignity of a teaching staff that the rector should be represented, but also the ethical requirements of a university of excellence which the University San Raffaele rightly aspires to be.
I would like to clearly and publicly and disassociate myself from these words and logic that underlies it, the logic that a lifetime fighting, always fighting as corporatism and clientelism of the Italian university system and the gradual sinking of all the criteria excellence and merit, as well as the University itself as a school of freedom.
I'll disagree individually, although I hope that the deprecation of what is unanimous among the faculty. But I would like to reiterate my statement that are not happy in principle nor in fact partly responsible Circulation of this ceremony, not of principle for the deep reasons of disagreement that I have expressed here, not a fact, because the effects are not included members of the Committee on the candidate in question, and certainly not because I asked to be exonerated.
-----------------------------
Cacciari defends professors
The controversy after the thesis defense of his daughter Prime Minister and a joke of the rector Don Verzè
The case - The clash between a teacher and rector
FAIR - Tuesday morning, in the classroom Leonardo da Vinci University Vita-Salute San Raffaele in Milan, she graduated with honors with 110 Barbara Berlusconi, daughter of Prime Minister and Veronica Lario, with a thesis on the concept of health freedom and justice in the thinking of Amartya Sen. During the announcement, the chancellor asked the Don Luigi Verzé neodottoressa if, in your opinion, can be born a Faculty of Economics of the San Raffaele based on the thought of Sen and asked to continue their studies and become a day teacher. In this classroom was Roberta De Monticelli, Professor of Philosophy of the person, the judging committee of the other four theses discussed that morning.
LE CRITICISM OF THE TEACHER - The teacher found inappropriate words of the rector of the premier and his daughter wrote a letter, released by Republic, which has deviated "openly and publicly." Yesterday the Corriere della Sera, the teacher reiterated his position saying that "every word is stone, it's location, and contribution to the clarity and honesty" and must be calibrated "according to role and context." The thesis supervisor Barbara Berlusconi, Roberto Mordacci, accused of "throwing mud on the work already done by the University." The teacher today further clarifies the principles that have animated his dissent. She says the Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy Michele Di Francesco and Massimo Cacciari vicar pro-rector.
------------------
THE 'CONTROLETTERA "
" Da Don Verzè a joke father "
Di Francesco and Cacciari: degree grades earned, not Exclusion for De Monticelli, enough with the insinuations
Milan - Given the continuing controversy regarding the recent release of Ms. Barbara Berlusconi's degree at the University Vita-Salute San Raffaele, I say the following.
There has been no "crowding out" intentional or unintentional (whatever that may be an unintended exclusion) of Professor De Monticelli degree by the Board of Mrs. Barbara Berlusconi, but only the appointment of a committee of which Professor De Monticelli did not belong, like they did not nine other colleagues of the faculty role (from Massimo Cacciari, Matteo Motterlini, Andrea Tagliapietra , Massimo Donà, etc.)..
Mrs. Barbara Berlusconi came to the session of graduation with an average of 108.37 / 110 (corresponding to 29.55 / 30) and ten awards. With a curriculum like this would be a surprise if he did not graduate with honors and not the other way.
The idea that a measure of paternal Verzé Don Rector, also repeated occasions in the past against other students, can be interpreted as a formal proposal to Mrs Barbara Berlusconi to join the faculty of the San Raffaele defies any standard of reasonableness and common sense. At the San Raffaele, as in any Italian university access teaching is governed by the laws governing the university competitions. In
therefore strongly rejected the allegations and insinuations damaging to the professionalism of colleagues in the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita-Salute San Raffaele, then we would like to invite those who want a less partial and misleading of the faculty of his mind and Its mission, to visit the website, so to get an idea of \u200b\u200bthe value its innovative teaching program, the prestige and quality of its teachers and their scientific production (reported in a special report in tribute to a model of transparency is rare in this country). On this, and not on gossip, the speculation, nothing, should be considered when teaching and research institution.
Michele Di Francesco
Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita-Salute San Raffaele
Massimo Cacciari
Deputy Vice Chancellor of the University Vita-Salute San Raffaele
----------------
The rejoinder
July 23
"Do not slander but sull'ateneo defend freedom critics'
I had the privilege of working, since my return in Italy, in the Faculty of Philosophy, perhaps more alive and new Italian university within a university that for the other faculty do not need any introduction. In this privileged adventure, I shared the founding of the Faculty, like all other colleagues, I have dedicated my best effort. My personal stance reiterated in the interview with Corriere yesterday after graduating from Barbara Berlusconi is taken away to the words spoken by the Rector, not an opinion on the work of the commission or its composition. The title says what I have said ("excluded from the Commission") in conversation with the journalist who reported correctly my thoughts. Not an attack, therefore, neither the degree to which our work Chancellor addressed, nor the committee that he tried, or issued by this court. Steer away from words that are considered demeaning is the exact opposite of throwing mud at an institution or work colleagues: You testifying their respect for the institution, its commitment to ethical principles proclaimed by the same founder and Rector and shared with all colleagues, and first among them the principle of freedom which is the heart and soul of the teaching of philosophy. You defend the meaning of their work- I would say more, the meaning of life. But not only its own: it is hard to defend the pride of every person, student or teacher, that attention to the weight and value of words, and respect for the rules and the law (outside of which only exists the empire of force) has been the reason for his life.
Roberta De Monticelli
Professor of Philosophy of the person
University Vita-Salute San Raffaele-
July 22, 2010 (Corriere.it)
degree to Barbara, there is a case
The charge of Professor . De Monticelli: violated the principle of equal dignity. The rapporteur
: mud on our work "There have been proposals for work and does not discriminate against other '
MILANO - Roberta De Monticelli, Professor of Philosophy at the University of the person Vita-Salute San Raffaele, found Tuesday morning it was quite unusual" excluded "from the jury by Barbara Berlusconi, daughter of Prime Minister and Veronica Lario, who graduated cum laude with a thesis on" The concept of well-being freedom and justice in the thinking of Amartya Sen, "Nobel Prize for Economics in 1998.
explains the surprise, "especially in relation to the fact that I was the only one that had been in committee the previous day, morning and evening, and it would have been for the four subsequent discussions that the young Berlusconi. " Do not want to do speculation, and especially points out: "I do not ever there was a suspicion that I was intentionally excluded." It simply observe the facts, driven by love for parresia, "telling the truth," that is convinced, "a Catholic soul, even as Don Verzé.
The teacher already holding in Geneva of the chair that once belonged to Jeanne Hersch (with Hannah Arendt and Raymond Klibansky the best student of Jaspers), recalls: "With my colleagues we had arranged to meet again the next morning at 9 Leonardo da Vinci in the classroom, which would be discussed in five theses. Was scheduled at 9.30 am the first candidate. My presence in the committee, however, was programmed from 10. Then I realized that the first was Barbara Berlusconi. " The announcement followed her in the audience. That is where, when Don Luis Verzé spoke, it was not recognized in the words of the rector. Roberta De Monticelli, in fact, "every word is stone, it's location, and contribution to the clarity and honesty," is calibrated on the basis of 'a role and context. " For this reason, the exchange between the rector and Barbara Berlusconi seemed "unreasonable": "Ask her, and not one of the other four graduates could arise if a faculty of Economics and the author's thought at issue in his case before the President of the Council, contained an implicit request for funding. And Barbara Berlusconi, who perhaps could also become a great economist, he answered "yes."
So he wrote a letter published by the Republic and taken up by other newspapers to "openly and publicly dissociate themselves from a breach of the principle of equal dignity." The university responded by stating that 'was not an offer of employment nor discriminate against other neodottori. He even added: "He who attends Don Luis knows that he considers our students are our first teachers. To stay, to continue studying, is the invitation he does, always, to everyone. " Hundreds of students and former students wrote to the professor to thank. No links at the San Raffaele. Yesterday, indeed, the faculty council was to establish herself among the "Any Other", the theme of the register kept by the rector. "They told me I absolutely disagree with my position in the manner and form."
on the content of the thesis, however, does not want to intervene: "I praise you would have if I had held that the claim had not been worthy. But I was not a committee, I can only rely on the opinion of colleagues. " It would be rather curious to read the final work done by Barbara Berlusconi: "I I had requested the secretariat to Veronica Milani, but there were no copies. " The thesis supervisor, Roberto Mordacci, welcomed the statements of my colleague with despair: "They throw mud on the work already done by the University. We will pay an image effect that is completely false to reality. She wanted to denounce this attitude a bit 'gigione by Don Luigi, but who knows him knows that he has done precisely that. He just wanted to encourage Barbara Berlusconi to become worthy of a post of lecturer. " And before closing states: "Here we are not all Berlusconi: I am writing to Europe and I worked on intellectual initiatives of the Democratic Party."
Elvira Serra
----------
LETTER
"That ceremony for Barbara Berlusconi has offended us teachers and our students'
A letter from a professor at the University San Raffaele after graduating daughter Premier
"The rector Don Verzè addressed only to her, in the presence of Prime Minister, offering a chair"
of Roberta De Monticelli
"That ceremony for Barbara Berlusconi has offended us teachers and our students'
teach philosophy of the person the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita Salute San Raffaele. I am writing this to say: not in my name. It is certainly not in my name that our rector, Father Louis Verzi, acting as his right to the ceremony of the proclamation of degrees, then turned to the only candidate Barbara Berlusconi, who arrived at the conclusion of his three-year course and asked if he thought he could be born a faculty of economics San Raffaele based on the author's thought on the issue in the thesis (Amartya Sen), and an invitation to become professor of this university, in the presence of the Prime Minister, who attended the ceremony.
mean openly and publicly disassociate myself from this I think is a violation not only of the formal principle of equal dignity of students, not only of form and substance of an act as a public proclamation of degree, not only the dignity of a teaching staff that the rector should be represented, but also the ethical requirements of a university of excellence which the University San Raffaele rightly aspires to be.
I would like to clearly and publicly and disassociate myself from these words and logic that underlies it, the logic that a lifetime fighting, always fighting as corporatism and clientelism of the Italian university system and the gradual sinking of all the criteria excellence and merit, as well as the University itself as a school of freedom.
I'll disagree individually, although I hope that the deprecation of what is unanimous among the faculty. But I would like to reiterate my statement that are not happy in principle nor in fact partly responsible Circulation of this ceremony, not of principle for the deep reasons of disagreement that I have expressed here, not a fact, because the effects are not included members of the Committee on the candidate in question, and certainly not because I asked to be exonerated.
-----------------------------
Cacciari defends professors
The controversy after the thesis defense of his daughter Prime Minister and a joke of the rector Don Verzè
The case - The clash between a teacher and rector
FAIR - Tuesday morning, in the classroom Leonardo da Vinci University Vita-Salute San Raffaele in Milan, she graduated with honors with 110 Barbara Berlusconi, daughter of Prime Minister and Veronica Lario, with a thesis on the concept of health freedom and justice in the thinking of Amartya Sen. During the announcement, the chancellor asked the Don Luigi Verzé neodottoressa if, in your opinion, can be born a Faculty of Economics of the San Raffaele based on the thought of Sen and asked to continue their studies and become a day teacher. In this classroom was Roberta De Monticelli, Professor of Philosophy of the person, the judging committee of the other four theses discussed that morning.
LE CRITICISM OF THE TEACHER - The teacher found inappropriate words of the rector of the premier and his daughter wrote a letter, released by Republic, which has deviated "openly and publicly." Yesterday the Corriere della Sera, the teacher reiterated his position saying that "every word is stone, it's location, and contribution to the clarity and honesty" and must be calibrated "according to role and context." The thesis supervisor Barbara Berlusconi, Roberto Mordacci, accused of "throwing mud on the work already done by the University." The teacher today further clarifies the principles that have animated his dissent. She says the Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy Michele Di Francesco and Massimo Cacciari vicar pro-rector.
------------------
THE 'CONTROLETTERA "
" Da Don Verzè a joke father "
Di Francesco and Cacciari: degree grades earned, not Exclusion for De Monticelli, enough with the insinuations
Milan - Given the continuing controversy regarding the recent release of Ms. Barbara Berlusconi's degree at the University Vita-Salute San Raffaele, I say the following.
There has been no "crowding out" intentional or unintentional (whatever that may be an unintended exclusion) of Professor De Monticelli degree by the Board of Mrs. Barbara Berlusconi, but only the appointment of a committee of which Professor De Monticelli did not belong, like they did not nine other colleagues of the faculty role (from Massimo Cacciari, Matteo Motterlini, Andrea Tagliapietra , Massimo Donà, etc.)..
Mrs. Barbara Berlusconi came to the session of graduation with an average of 108.37 / 110 (corresponding to 29.55 / 30) and ten awards. With a curriculum like this would be a surprise if he did not graduate with honors and not the other way.
The idea that a measure of paternal Verzé Don Rector, also repeated occasions in the past against other students, can be interpreted as a formal proposal to Mrs Barbara Berlusconi to join the faculty of the San Raffaele defies any standard of reasonableness and common sense. At the San Raffaele, as in any Italian university access teaching is governed by the laws governing the university competitions. In
therefore strongly rejected the allegations and insinuations damaging to the professionalism of colleagues in the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita-Salute San Raffaele, then we would like to invite those who want a less partial and misleading of the faculty of his mind and Its mission, to visit the website, so to get an idea of \u200b\u200bthe value its innovative teaching program, the prestige and quality of its teachers and their scientific production (reported in a special report in tribute to a model of transparency is rare in this country). On this, and not on gossip, the speculation, nothing, should be considered when teaching and research institution.
Michele Di Francesco
Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy, University Vita-Salute San Raffaele
Massimo Cacciari
Deputy Vice Chancellor of the University Vita-Salute San Raffaele
----------------
The rejoinder
July 23
"Do not slander but sull'ateneo defend freedom critics'
I had the privilege of working, since my return in Italy, in the Faculty of Philosophy, perhaps more alive and new Italian university within a university that for the other faculty do not need any introduction. In this privileged adventure, I shared the founding of the Faculty, like all other colleagues, I have dedicated my best effort. My personal stance reiterated in the interview with Corriere yesterday after graduating from Barbara Berlusconi is taken away to the words spoken by the Rector, not an opinion on the work of the commission or its composition. The title says what I have said ("excluded from the Commission") in conversation with the journalist who reported correctly my thoughts. Not an attack, therefore, neither the degree to which our work Chancellor addressed, nor the committee that he tried, or issued by this court. Steer away from words that are considered demeaning is the exact opposite of throwing mud at an institution or work colleagues: You testifying their respect for the institution, its commitment to ethical principles proclaimed by the same founder and Rector and shared with all colleagues, and first among them the principle of freedom which is the heart and soul of the teaching of philosophy. You defend the meaning of their work- I would say more, the meaning of life. But not only its own: it is hard to defend the pride of every person, student or teacher, that attention to the weight and value of words, and respect for the rules and the law (outside of which only exists the empire of force) has been the reason for his life.
Roberta De Monticelli
Professor of Philosophy of the person
University Vita-Salute San Raffaele-
0 comments:
Post a Comment